Despite the fact that known evidence disproves the legend and that most serious historians reject it, a new movie based on the myth of 'Pope Joan' has risen to the top 10 list in Italian cinema. Once again, it seems apropos that Catholics refresh their memories regarding this legend which was previously believed even by Catholics. To that end, please recall that...
* The first mention of 'Pope Joan' did not occur until centuries after her supposed existence
* 'Pope Joan' does not fit in the historical timeline
* There is no solid evidence for the legend, and there are contrary explanations for various supposed "proofs" (e.g. chairs with holes do not prove there was a 'Pope Joan', because chairs with holes predate the legend)
* Even enemies of the Church today admit the story is a fable
* In the past, this legend has been used to tarnish the reputation of the Church. It has also been used by feminists to advance their agenda
Related: Vatican Q & A: Was there ever a "Pope Joan"? | The Popes: From St. Peter to Present | Top Reasons Why Women Can't Be Priests
Posts
